So when it comes to drinking one of the OGs of cocktails (Martini and Manhattan being the others) are you old fashioned? What I am referring to, actually, is how you make or take your Old-Fashioned. But before I dive into that let me provide a little bit of the cocktail’s history.
The Old-Fashioned was not always called…well, an Old-Fashioned. Its estimated induction and popularity began circa the middle 19th century and was commonly referred to as the Whiskey Cocktail. As far back as the Civil War era, the Whiskey Cocktail recipe was one composed of whiskey, sugar, bitters and water with a lemon peel twist as garnish. That’s it! If that sounds a bit familiar to what you may find in some of today’s Old-Fashioned offerings, you’re not wrong. But where did the name “Old-Fashioned” come from and how did we get to today’s present concoctions of the cocktail?
During the 1870’s and 1880’s, the Whiskey Cocktail became more and more en vogue. It was simple and very popular especially in cities like Chicago and New York. However, because of its fashionableness (yes that’s a word), restaurant proprietors and bartenders took liberties with how the drink could be upgraded and refined in an attempt to draw new and younger patrons. New creations called for the addition of certain liqueurs, fruit and even soda to the recipe. Of course, this didn’t sit well with the whiskey cocktail purists of the time. Not at all. These ever reliable drinkers decried the variations to their once favored offering, calling them sacrilegious and overly complicated. What they wanted was their usual, their familiar and not an ingredients list. Hell, what they really wanted was their damn,”old-fashioned” cocktail. Get it?
So getting back to the original question. Are you old fashioned? If you’re anything like me, the fewer ingredients the better. Bourbon, a sugar cube, water (or simple syrup), Angostura bitters, one large ice cube, all topped with a lemon or orange twist is my preferred recipe. So if you happen to be in agreement, if the cut of your jib sails as mine, then you too are old fashioned about your Old-Fashioned.
But just in case you’re not, I’ve provided a few alternative recipes below. Cheers!
The Rum Old-Fashioned
2oz your favorite rum
1 lump cane sugar
2 dashes of Angostura bitters
1 Large ice cube
Lime twist
The Brandy Old-Fashioned (Wisconsin style)
2oz your favorite brandy
1 sugar cube
4 dashes Angostura bitters
2 orange slices
2 cherries
Sprite or 7Up
The Clint Eastwood
2 oz your favorite rye
3/4 tsp Angostura bitters
3/4 tsp green Chartreuse
1/4 oz Demerara syrup
Orange twist
-The Bourboneer
References:
Image by Liqour.com
“The Old-Fashioned”, Robert Simpson. Ten Speed Press, Crown Publishing, 2014, New York.